Posts Tagged Gadi Barlevy
Upfront Bonus to Teachers Improves Student Performance
Posted by psychieblogger in Children and Teens, Derek Neal, Psychology, Research, Significant Impact, Standardized Tests, Student Academic Performance, Student Achievement, Student Performance, Students, Teacher Incentives, Work and Career on August 9, 2012
Educational reform is receiving considerable attention these days, and a new study suggests prepaying teachers appears to improve student academic performance.
Paying an upfront bonus does come with a caveat as part of the money must be returned if student performance fails to improve, say University of Chicago researchers.
The study showed that students gained as much as a 10 percentile increase in their scores compared to students with similar backgrounds — if their teacher received a bonus at the beginning of the year, with conditions attached.
There was no gain for students when teachers were offered the bonus at the end of the school year, the research found.
“This is the first experimental study to demonstrate that teacher merit pay can have a significant impact on student performance in the U.S.,” said economist John List, Ph.D., an author of the study.
The study, published by the National Bureau of Economics Research, reflects the findings of other studies in psychology and behavioral economics.
“The results of our experiment are consistent with over 30 years of psychological and economic research on the power of loss aversion to motivate behavior: Students whose teachers in the ‘loss’ treatment of the experiment showed large and significant gains in their math test scores,” said List, a professor in economics at UChicago.
Timing of the incentive made a significant difference.
“In line with previous studies in the United States, we did not find an impact of teacher incentives that are framed as gains (the reward coming at the end of the year),” he added.
The study comes amid a growing wave of interest of finding ways to provide teacher incentives to increase student performance — as usually assessed by student achievement on standardized tests. Unfortunately, most of the current incentive programs have not shown value, the scholars said.
The new study depends on a formula developed by Dr. Derek Neal, professor of economics at UChicago, and Gadi Barlevy, an economist with the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago.
They devised the “pay for percentile” method of measuring teacher performance by comparing individual students with similar backgrounds and achievement to see what impact a teacher had on their learning.
The scholars used the formula in an experiment in Chicago Heights, Ill., a community 30 miles south of Chicago. The community has nine kindergarten to eighth-grade schools with a total enrollment of 3,200 students. Its achievement rates are below state average, and 98 percent of the students are eligible for free or reduced lunches.
At the beginning of the school year, the teachers were introduced to the experiment and offered an opportunity to participate. A total of 150 of the 160 teachers agreed to join in the study, which was supported by the local teachers union.
The teachers were randomly assigned to a control group as well as a group given a bonus at the beginning of the year, a group that could receive the bonus at the end of the year, and a group made up of teachers who worked in teams. Money for the bonuses was provided from private sources.
One group of teachers in the study was given a $4,000 bonus at the beginning of the year and told it would be reduced by an amount reflecting their students’ performance — the more the students’ standardized scores increased, the more of the bonus their teacher could keep. Another group of teachers was told they would receive a $4,000 bonus if their students improved during the year.
The incentives were based on rewarding teachers with $80 for each percentile of increase in their students’ mathematics performance over the district average. They could, depending on exceptional student performance, receive up to $8,000 under the plan — the equivalent of 16 percent of the average teacher salary in the district.
The students were tested with the ThinkLink Predictive Assessment, a standardized, non-high-stakes diagnostic tool that is aligned with state achievement tests.
Thomas Amadio, superintendent of Chicago Heights Elementary School District 170, where the experiment was conducted, said the study shows the value of merit pay as an encouragement for better teacher performance.
“Teachers do have challenges, and classes can vary from year to year in how well they perform. Testing students individually to see their growth is a valuable measure, however,” he said.
Teachers responsible for that growth should be rewarded, he said.
Source: University of Chicago
Advocacy and Policy, Behavioral economics, Caveat, Chicago Heights, Chicago Researchers, Derek Neal, Dr Derek, Economic Research, Economics Research, Economist John, Educational Reform, Experimental Study, Featured, Field Experiment, Gadi Barlevy, Incentive Programs, John List, LifeHelper, Loss Aversion, Math Test, Merit Pay, Percentile, Professional, Thomas Amadio, United States
find out…
In the cloud….
Abuse achievement Addiction Adolescence Advocacy and Policy Aging Alcoholism American Psychological Association Anxiety Biological Psychiatry Brain and Behavior Canada care Cognition Compact Disc Current Dialectical behavior therapy Doctor of Psychology Education Emotion Exercise/Fitness Featured Feeling Feelings Gender General Genetics health Investigators Job Journal of Neuroscience Journal Reference LifeHelper love Magnetic resonance imaging Major Depression Marriage Medical News Today Medications Memory and Perception mental-health Mental Health and Wellness mental psych mind Mindfulness MRI Neuropsychology and Neurology Occupation odds Ohio State University PA Pain Parenting Parents partner People Personality Personality and Social Psychology Review Personality development Pharmacology Professional PsychCentral Psychological Science Psychotherapy PTSD Relationship Relationships Relationships and Sexuality Researcher Risk Factor self help Society for Personality and Social Psychology Story Source Stress Response United Statestype of post….
- 3 Fatty Acids (1)
- Abstract Thinking (1)
- ADHD (4)
- Admiration (1)
- Affective Neuroscience (20)
- Albert Einstein (1)
- Albert Einstein College (1)
- Albert Einstein College Of Medicine (1)
- Allure (1)
- Alphas (1)
- American Chemical Society (1)
- American Psychological Association (3)
- Antisocial Behavior (1)
- Antiviral Properties (1)
- Apparent Differences (1)
- Appearance (1)
- Atypical Antipsychotic Drugs (1)
- Autism Research (1)
- Balanced Diet (1)
- Beha (1)
- Behavior Traits (1)
- Behavioral Therapy (1)
- Benefactor (1)
- Benefit From (1)
- Beth Cohen (1)
- Bipolar (1)
- Bipolar Patients (1)
- Bobby Thomas (1)
- Body Chemistry (1)
- Boston Children (1)
- Brad Bushman (1)
- Brain Area (1)
- Brain Bank (1)
- Brain Changes (1)
- Brain Connections (1)
- Brain Health (1)
- Brain Mass (1)
- Brain Synapses (1)
- Brian Wansink (1)
- California State University (1)
- Calorie Counting (1)
- Canada (1)
- Canadian Forces (1)
- Candy Bar (1)
- Carnegie Mellon University (1)
- Carnevale (1)
- Cell Cultures (1)
- Centers For Disease Control (1)
- Centers For Disease Control And Prevention (1)
- Chemical Changes (1)
- Chemical Compounds (2)
- Chemistry Institute (1)
- Children and Teens (14)
- Children With Autism (1)
- Chocolate Blueberries (1)
- Chronic Administration (1)
- Chronic Treatment (1)
- Clout (1)
- Clozapine (1)
- Cocoa Drink (1)
- Cocoa Flavanols (1)
- Cocoa Plants (1)
- Cocoa Products (1)
- Cognition And Perception (1)
- Cognitive Health (1)
- Cognitive Impairment (1)
- Cognitive Tests (1)
- College Age Men (1)
- College Age Students (1)
- College Age Women (1)
- Common Cold Virus (1)
- Common Foods (1)
- Conjunctivitis (1)
- Construal (1)
- Control Experts (1)
- Control Self (1)
- Cornell University (1)
- Coxsackieviruses (1)
- Dan Ariely (1)
- David Creswell (1)
- Davis Researchers (1)
- Deborah Serani (1)
- Defective Gene (1)
- Depakene (1)
- Depressed Patients (1)
- Depression (21)
- Derek Neal (1)
- Detrimental Consequences (1)
- Detrimental Effect (2)
- Dialectical behavior therapy (10)
- Diet Exercise (1)
- Dietary Recommendations (1)
- Disease Control And Prevention (1)
- Dna Damage (1)
- Doctor of Psychology (18)
- Dominic Holland (1)
- Donations (1)
- Drug Molecules (1)
- Drug Resistance (1)
- Duke University (1)
- Duman (1)
- Education (7)
- Einstein College Of Medicine (1)
- Elisabeth Haug (1)
- Emotion (27)
- Energy Use (1)
- Enterovirus Infections (1)
- Environmental Factors (1)
- Expressive Writing (1)
- Family (6)
- Feeling (7)
- Finding Love Again (1)
- Flavor Components (1)
- Florida State University (1)
- Fluoxetine (1)
- Focus Group (1)
- Food Environments (1)
- Foods And Beverages (1)
- Frank Discussions (1)
- Free Radicals (1)
- Fujita (1)
- Fundraiser (1)
- Fundraisers (1)
- Fundraising Goals (1)
- Garry Chick (1)
- Gene Activation (1)
- Gene Change (1)
- Gene Defect (1)
- Genetic Reasons (1)
- Genetic Switch (1)
- Genetic Variety (1)
- Good Nutrition (1)
- Groundbreaking Study (1)
- Group Conversations (1)
- Harvard Medical School (2)
- Health Study (1)
- Health-related (41)
- Healthful Choices (1)
- Hedonism (1)
- High Throughput Screening (1)
- Highest Education (1)
- Hillside Hospital (1)
- History Of Marijuana (1)
- Hourly Rate (1)
- Immediate Gratification (1)
- Incentives (1)
- India (1)
- Influence Individuals (1)
- Insulin Resistance (1)
- Jane Dutton (1)
- Javier Gonzalez (1)
- Jean Twenge (1)
- John Fletcher (1)
- Journal Entries (1)
- Journal Hypertension (1)
- Journal Nature Neuroscience (1)
- Journal Of Personality (1)
- Journal Of Personality And Social Psychology (1)
- Kansas State University (2)
- Laboratory Tests (1)
- Lack Of Time (1)
- Litter Mates (1)
- Long Island Ny (1)
- Longstanding Puzzle (1)
- Losing Weight (1)
- Manic Depressive Disorder (1)
- Many Young Adults (1)
- Marc Sommer (1)
- Margaret Sheridan (1)
- Massachusetts General Hospital (1)
- Media Messages (1)
- Medicine Report (1)
- Memory Task (1)
- Mental Alertness (1)
- Mental Health (10)
- Michael Sporn (1)
- Michigan State University (1)
- Mild Cognitive Impairment Mci (1)
- Molecular Energy (1)
- Molecular Screening (1)
- Mood Effects (1)
- Mood Enhancers (1)
- Mood Modulators (1)
- Mood Swings (1)
- Motivation (1)
- Motor Responses (1)
- Mount Sinai School (2)
- Mount Sinai School Of Medicine (2)
- Mouse Models (1)
- Mouse Study (1)
- Mssr (1)
- National Autonomous University (1)
- National Autonomous University Of Mexico (1)
- Negative Changes (1)
- Neurons In The Brain (1)
- Neuropsychological Tests (1)
- Northeastern University (1)
- Northwestern University (1)
- Notre Dame (1)
- Nutritional Counselors (1)
- OCD (1)
- odds (7)
- Ohio State University (3)
- Omega 3 Fatty Acids (1)
- Organizational Settings (1)
- Outlook Help (1)
- Parenting & Children (6)
- Paul Patterson (1)
- Penn State University (1)
- Personality Psychology (1)
- Pines Institute (1)
- Postdoctoral Researcher (1)
- Premorbid (1)
- Prestige (1)
- Prior Research (1)
- Prominence (1)
- Psychiatry Research (1)
- Psychological Bulletin (1)
- Psychological Science (6)
- Psychology (50)
- Psychotic Symptoms (1)
- PTSD (5)
- Quebec National Assembly (1)
- Racial Background (1)
- Receipt (1)
- Red Wine (1)
- Reducing Stress (1)
- Reflection (1)
- Repetitive Behavior (1)
- Research (85)
- Restrictive Diets (1)
- Rich Cocoa (1)
- Robert Wright (1)
- Sackler Faculty (1)
- Sadness (2)
- San Diego State University (1)
- Sanctuary (1)
- Saturday June (1)
- Scant Attention (1)
- Scarf (1)
- Scary (1)
- SCD (1)
- Scenarios (2)
- Schizophreni (1)
- Schizophrenia (10)
- Schizophrenia Patients (2)
- Schizophrenic Patient (1)
- Schizophrenic Patients (2)
- School (2)
- School Counselor (1)
- School Detention (1)
- School Of Medicine (1)
- Schwabe (2)
- science (2)
- Science And Technology (1)
- Science Source (1)
- Science Technology (1)
- Seclusion (1)
- Secret Government (1)
- Self Awareness (1)
- Self Control (1)
- Self Experience (1)
- Self Harm (2)
- self help (3)
- Self Perception (2)
- Self-esteem (9)
- Senior Adults (1)
- Senior Moments (1)
- Seniors (2)
- Sense Of Humor (1)
- Sense Of Self (1)
- Separate Entities (1)
- Separate Ways (1)
- Serani (1)
- Serious Danger (1)
- Serotonin (1)
- Severity (1)
- Sex (3)
- Sex Provider (1)
- Sex Roles (1)
- Sex Workers (1)
- Sexual Assault Victim (1)
- Sexual Encounters (1)
- Sexual selection (1)
- Shame (1)
- Sharp Edge (1)
- Shattered Dreams (1)
- Sheba Medical Center (1)
- Shlomi (1)
- Short Stories (1)
- Short Term Memory (1)
- Siberian Hamsters (1)
- Sibling Pairs (1)
- Sick Time (1)
- Sicknesses (1)
- Significant Impact (1)
- Signs Of Depression (1)
- Simulation Training (1)
- Single (music) (1)
- Single Day (1)
- Six Months (1)
- Skipping Meals (1)
- Skipping School (1)
- Sleep (8)
- Sleep Disorders (1)
- Sleep Disturbances (1)
- Sleep Loss (1)
- Sleep Patterns (1)
- Sleep Problems (1)
- Sleep Timer (1)
- Slow-Carb Diet (1)
- Smart Comments (1)
- Smoking Marijuana (1)
- Social Anxiety (1)
- Social Attachments (1)
- Social Behavior (1)
- Social Connectedness (1)
- Social Connections (1)
- Social Interactions (1)
- Social Issues (1)
- Social Ladder (1)
- Social Networking (2)
- Social Networks (1)
- Social Phobia (2)
- Social Relationships (1)
- Societal Problems (1)
- society (1)
- Society for Personality and Social Psychology (5)
- Sociologists (1)
- software-development (1)
- Sophomore (1)
- Sore Throats (1)
- Sorrow (1)
- Sounds (2)
- Spatial Abilities (1)
- Spatial Skills (1)
- Specific Foods (1)
- Spectrum Disorder (1)
- Speech Recognition Software (1)
- Spending Time With Family (1)
- Spirituality (1)
- Spite (1)
- Spontaneous Experience (1)
- Sporting Clubs (1)
- Sports Medicine (1)
- Spot The Difference (1)
- Spot The Difference Game (1)
- Stages Of Schizophrenia (1)
- Stalker (1)
- Standardized Tests (1)
- Stansbury (1)
- State Illinois (1)
- State Wisconsin (1)
- Stay At Home (1)
- Stay At Home Mom (1)
- Stay Home (1)
- Steady Source (1)
- Stem Cells (2)
- Steps (group) (1)
- Stereotype (1)
- Stereotyped Behaviors (1)
- Stevens Point (1)
- Stomach (1)
- Story Technology (1)
- Strange Face (1)
- Strange Thoughts (1)
- Stream Of Consciousness (1)
- Streetlight (1)
- Stress (17)
- Stress Changes (1)
- Stress hormone (2)
- Stress Hormones (1)
- Stress Levels (1)
- Stress Reduction (3)
- Stress Response (2)
- Stressed Individuals (1)
- Stressful Event (1)
- Stressors (1)
- Strife (1)
- Striking Similarity (1)
- Striking Variation (1)
- Stroke Prevention (2)
- Strong Woman (1)
- Strous (1)
- Structure And Function Of The Brain (1)
- Student (1)
- Student Academic Performance (1)
- Student Achievement (1)
- Student Affairs Professionals (1)
- Student Performance (1)
- Student Researchers (1)
- Students (11)
- Students Ages (2)
- Study Author (1)
- Study Findings (2)
- Study Group (1)
- Study Investigators (2)
- Study Participants (5)
- Study Researchers (9)
- Study Reveals That (1)
- Study Subjects (1)
- Study Suggests That (2)
- Study Women (1)
- Stuff (1)
- Substance abuse (4)
- Substance Use (1)
- Subtle Differences (1)
- Subtle Disturbances (1)
- Suicidal Thoughts (1)
- Suicide (5)
- Suicide Note (1)
- Suicide Risk (1)
- Suitcase (1)
- Sun Night (1)
- Supervision (1)
- Supportive Care (1)
- Susan J. Elliott (1)
- Suspicions (1)
- Suzanne Burgoyne (1)
- Sway (1)
- Sweden (1)
- Switch Languages (1)
- Sympathy (1)
- Symptoms Of Depression (2)
- Symptoms Of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (2)
- Symptoms Of Schizophrenia (1)
- Synaptic Connections (1)
- Taking Your Mind (1)
- Talents (1)
- Tantrum (1)
- Target (1)
- Teacher Incentives (1)
- Teacher Ratings (1)
- Technological Workforce (1)
- Technology (13)
- Technology Engineering (1)
- ted (1)
- Teen Drinking (1)
- Teen Issues (4)
- Teenage Boy (1)
- Teenage Years (1)
- Teens (1)
- Tel Aviv University (1)
- Telling The Truth (1)
- Term Alcohol (1)
- Term Consequences (1)
- Term Experts (1)
- Term Goals (1)
- Text Message (1)
- Text Messages (1)
- Texts (1)
- Thanx (1)
- The Emotional Toolkit: Seven Power-Skills to Nail Your Bad Feelings (1)
- The Power of a Positive No: How to Say No and Still Get to Yes (1)
- Therapeutic Effects (1)
- Therapy? (9)
- Thinking About Things (1)
- Third Ventricle (1)
- Thomas Mussweiler (1)
- Thought (3)
- Thought Disorder (1)
- Thoughts And Feelings (1)
- Thoughts In My Head (1)
- Thousands Of Dollars (1)
- tight muscles (1)
- Tim (1)
- Time Caretaker (1)
- Time Honored Tradition (1)
- Time limit (video game terminology) (1)
- Time Researchers (1)
- Time With Family (1)
- Timer Function (1)
- Timothy Ferriss (1)
- Tissue Loss (1)
- Tnjpoetry (1)
- Today's Healthcare (4)
- Tolcapone (1)
- Tolerance Policy (1)
- Total Population (1)
- Tough Love (1)
- Tourism Management (1)
- Tracking Technology (1)
- Train Health Professionals (1)
- Train Psychologists (1)
- Training Period (1)
- Transcription Factor (1)
- Transgression (1)
- Transition From High School To College (1)
- Trauma (1)
- Traumatic Stress Disorder (4)
- travel (1)
- Treating Schizophrenia (1)
- Treatment For Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (1)
- Treatment group (1)
- Treatment Regime (1)
- Treatment Resistance (1)
- Triterpenoid (1)
- Trojan (1)
- Troubled Relationship (1)
- Tumor Necrosis Factor (1)
- Type 2 Diabetes (1)
- Typical Schedule (1)
- Uc San Diego (1)
- Ucla Researchers (2)
- Ucla Scientists (1)
- Ulsan (1)
- Unanswered Questions (1)
- Uncategorized (110)
- Uncertainty (1)
- Unclothed (1)
- Unconditioned Stimulus (1)
- Underpinnings (1)
- Undesirable Behavior (1)
- Undying Support (1)
- Unfairness (1)
- Unhealthy Behaviors (2)
- Unhealthy Food (2)
- United Kindom (1)
- United States (1)
- University Medical Center (1)
- University Of California Berkeley (1)
- University Of California Davis (1)
- University Of California Los Angeles (1)
- University Of California San Diego (2)
- University Of California San Francisco (2)
- University Of Chile (1)
- University Of Massachusetts (1)
- University of Michigan (1)
- University Of Milan (1)
- University of Notre Dame (1)
- University Of Oxford (1)
- University Of Pennsylvania (1)
- University Of Queensland (1)
- University Of Queensland Australia (1)
- University Of Science And Technology (1)
- University Of The Witwatersrand (1)
- University Of Warwick (1)
- University Researcher (1)
- University Researchers (2)
- Unreal (1)
- Unsung Heroes (1)
- Ups (2)
- Ups And Downs (1)
- Urban Area (1)
- Urge (1)
- Urges (1)
- Ury (1)
- Using Imaging (1)
- vacation (2)
- Vacations (2)
- Valproic Acid (1)
- Vandalism (1)
- Vascular Surgeon (1)
- Verbal Fluency (1)
- Verbal Memory (1)
- Vets (1)
- Vicious Cycle (1)
- Video Surveillance (1)
- Videos (1)
- Violence and Abuse (1)
- Viral Infection (1)
- Virology (1)
- Virtual Patients (1)
- Virtual Reality Laboratory (1)
- Virtual Reality Technology (1)
- Virtual Simulations (1)
- Virtues (1)
- Viruses (1)
- Visu (1)
- Visua (1)
- Visual Attention (2)
- Visual Decision (1)
- Visual Stimuli (1)
- Visual Tasks (1)
- Vital Subject (1)
- Vitamin Deficiency (1)
- Voice Directions (1)
- Volume Loss (1)
- Voluntary Effort (1)
- Vulnerability (1)
- Vulnerable Individuals (1)
- Vulnerable Times (1)
- Waist Circumference (1)
- Wansink (1)
- Wayne State University (1)
- Weather Prediction (1)
- Web Activities (1)
- Weight loss (1)
- Weight Values (1)
- Weights (1)
- Western Countries (1)
- Western Culture (1)
- Western Societies (1)
- Wh (1)
- What The Heck (1)
- White Lies (1)
- White Matter (3)
- Whole Brain (1)
- William Ury (1)
- Windowsill (1)
- Wine Drinkers (1)
- Witch (1)
- Womb (1)
- women (20)
- Work (1)
- Work and Career (23)
- Work Demonstrates That (1)
- Work Groups (1)
- Workaholic (1)
- Working Memory (3)
- Workout (1)
- Workplace Health (1)
- Worktop (1)
- World Depression (1)
- World Development (1)
- World Researchers (1)
- Worries (1)
- Worst Time (1)
- Wounds and Healing (1)
- Yale Scientists (1)
- Year 1 (1)
- Yeoman (1)
- Yoga (1)
- Yohimbine (1)
- Young Adulthood (1)
- Young Adults (2)
- Young Boys (1)
- Young Woman (1)
- Younger Boy (1)
- Younger Men (1)
- Youngsters (1)
- YourTango (1)
- Youth (1)
- Youth Group (1)
- Youth Groups (1)
- Zago (1)
- Zheng Wang (1)
- Zhou (1)
Best of ours..
must watch...
- None
get your wp….
feedburner
grab from past….
- August 2012 (68)
- July 2012 (100)
- June 2012 (36)
- January 2012 (1)
We are on google+
December 2019 M T W T F S S « Aug 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 Blog Stats
- 2,353 hits
me
Blogroll